M. Toner et al., NONEQUILIBRIUM FREEZING OF ONE-CELL MOUSE EMBRYOS - MEMBRANE INTEGRITY AND DEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL, Biophysical journal, 64(6), 1993, pp. 1908-1921
A thermodynamic model was used to evaluate and optimize a rapid three-
step rapid three-step nonequilibrium freezing protocol for one-cell mo
use embryos in the absence of cryoprotectants (CPAs) that avoided leth
al intracellular ice formation (IIF). Biophysical parameters of one-ce
ll mouse embryos were determined at subzero temperatures using cryomic
roscopic investigations (i.e., the water permeability of the plasma me
mbrane, its temperature dependence, and the parameters for heterogeneo
us IIF). The parameters were then incorporated into the thermodynamic
model, which predicted the likelihood of IIF. Model predictions showed
that IIF could be prevented at a cooling rate of 120-degrees-C/min wh
en a 5-min holding period was inserted at -10-degrees-C to assure cell
ular dehydration. This predicted freezing protocol, which avoided IIF
in the absence of CPAs, was two orders of magnitude faster than conven
tional embryo cryopreservation cooling rates of between 0.5 and 1-degr
ees-C/min. At slow cooling rates, embryos predominantly follow the equ
ilibrium phase diagram and do not undergo IIF, but mechanisms other th
at IIF (e.g., high electrolyte concentrations, mechanical effects, and
others) cause cellular damage. We tested the predictions of our therm
odynamic model using a programmable freezer and confirmed the theoreti
cal predictions. The membrane integrity of one-cell mouse embryos, as
assessed by fluorescein diacetate retention, was approximately 80% aft
er freezing down to -45-degrees-C by the rapid nonequilibrium protocol
derived from our model. The fact that embryos could be rapidly frozen
in the absence of CPAs without damage to the plasma membrane as asses
sed by fluorescein diacetate retention is a new and exciting finding.
Further refinements of this protocol is necessary to retain the develo
pmental competence of the embryos.