Cs. Bretherton et C. Schar, FLUX OF POTENTIAL VORTICITY SUBSTANCE - A SIMPLE DERIVATION AND A UNIQUENESS PROPERTY, Journal of the atmospheric sciences, 50(12), 1993, pp. 1834-1836
It is well known that even in the presence of diabatic effects a conse
rvation law exists for potential vorticity Q in the form partial deriv
ative (rhoQ)/partial derivative t + del . J = 0, where J is a flux of
potential vorticity substance. A new and extremely simple proof of thi
s result is presented that uses only one fact: the vorticity vector is
nondivergent. The flux vector derived by this method differs from tha
t of Haynes and McIntyre by a divergence-free vector, calling attentio
n to the nonuniqueness of J. It is proved, however, that the Haynes-Mc
Intyre flux vector is the unique choice that is the sum of a purely ad
vective flux and a nonadvective flux that depends linearly on local he
ating rate and frictional forces.