Alarm systems of ventilators enhance detection of possible critical ev
ents during artificial ventilation. Due to their significance, in some
countries the alarm detection of ventilators is regulated by federal
law. Up to now, no recommendations for the adjustment of alarm limits
exist and only a few detailed investigations of the accuracy of alarm
detection are available. Methods. The response of four commercially av
ailable ventilators (Servo-ventilator 900C, Siemens, Inc.; Bennett 720
0a, Hoyer, Inc.; Veolar, Hamilton, Inc.; EVITA, Drager, Inc.) to criti
cal events during artificial ventilation of a test lung were evaluated
. We measured the alarm time (the time between event creation and alar
m response) of ten different simulated critical events including disco
nnection, differentsized leaks, failure of the gas supply, and obstruc
tion at different places in the artificial airway. Discussion. All res
pirators were able to recognise severe critical situations such as hos
e disconnection, failure of gas supply, and total airway obstruction w
ithin a short time (< 15 s). The recognition of small airway leaks was
more difficult for the ventilators even when the alarm thresholds wer
e close. The alarm detection of the EVITA (software 10.0 or less) unde
r conditions of partial airway obstruction may be a source of risk for
the patient as the machine continued supplying inspiration with press
ure-limited ventilation even when the pressure threshold was reached.