T. Trabasso et S. Suh, UNDERSTANDING TEXT - ACHIEVING EXPLANATORY COHERENCE THROUGH ONLINE INFERENCES AND MENTAL OPERATIONS IN WORKING-MEMORY, Discourse processes, 16(1-2), 1993, pp. 3-34
The question of whether global, causal inferences are made during comp
rehension is studied following a three-pronged approach. First, potent
ial inferences were first identified a priori in texts generated by th
e causal network model for narrative discourse. Second, verbal protoco
l data in the form of ''talking aloud'' during the reading of sentence
s in stories were used to evaluate whether or not people made the pred
icted inferences. The global, causal inferences occurred where anticip
ated by the discourse analysis. The talk-aloud data also revealed that
subjects used four main mental operations during comprehension of a t
ext sentence: maintaining, retrieving, elaborating, and explaining. Th
ird, the talk-aloud data predicted recognition priming of superordinat
e goal statements, reading times of sentences, coherence ratings of st
ories, and long-term retention of stories. The data are discussed with
reference to constructivist versus minimalist processing claims, work
ing-memory models, and what verbal protocols reveal about processing.