Although most surveys show overwhelming support for old-age benefits a
mong people of all ages, few surveys cover cost-benefit trade-offs in
aging policy. Questions piloted by the American National Election Stud
ies in 1991 surveyed attitudes not only about Social Security and Medi
care expansion but also about taxes on Social Security benefits and th
e trade-off between increasing taxes and reducing elderly medical bene
fits. Path analysis is used to examine the influences on these benefit
, tax, and cost-benefit trade-off items for elderly and nonelderly res
pondents. Attitudes toward taxes on Social Security benefits are shape
d more by self-interest, and less by partisanship and ideology, than b
y attitudes toward benefits and cost-benefit trade-offs. Although ther
e is some evidence of generational conflict, there is more conflict wi
thin generations than between them.