P. Peltonensainio et al., PHENOTYPIC STABILITY OF OATS MEASURED WITH DIFFERENT STABILITY ANALYSES, Journal of Agricultural Science, 121, 1993, pp. 13-19
The phenotypic stability of seven Finnish and Nordic oat cultivars and
12 breeding lines developed at the Hankkija Plant Breeding Institute,
Finland, was studied using the Finlay-Wilkinson regression method, Eb
erhart-Russell stability analysis, principal component analysis (PCA)
with biplot presentation, canonical variate analysis (CVA) and Procrus
tes analysis. Comparison of stability analyses was based on four dissi
milar growing seasons. In addition to the measurement of phenotypic st
ability of grain yield, the performance of 12 morpho-physiological tra
its was evaluated, including maturity class and structure of canopy an
d plant stand. The different stability analyses examined produced unif
orm results and ranked the cultivars and breeding lines without major
disagreements. Lines with exceptionally stable yield performance over
the different growing seasons were identified. In general, there was a
n association of high yielding ability with poor stability. However, s
ome cultivars deviated from this tendency and showed high grain yield
production and average stability of yield performance.