La. Becker et al., DETECTION OF INTRACRANIAL TUMORS, SUBARACHNOID HEMORRHAGES, AND SUBDURAL HEMATOMAS IN PRIMARY-CARE PATIENTS - A REPORT FROM ASPN .2., Journal of family practice, 37(2), 1993, pp. 135-141
Background. The initial diagnosis of intracranial tumor, subarachnoid
hemorrhage (SAH), and subdural hematoma (SDH) can be difficult. This s
tudy was undertaken to determine the incidence and presenting signs an
d symptoms of these disorders in primary care settings, and to determi
ne whether a more aggressive investigative strategy for patients with
headache is justifiable. Methods. Weekly return cards and a chart audi
t were used to collect data over a 19-month period on every patient wh
o had a new diagnosis of intracranial tumor, SAH, or SDH. Age and sex
reports were collected annually. Results. Twenty-five new tumors, 17 S
AHs, and 8 SDHs were reported in 58 practices (a rate of 12/100,000 pa
tients per year). Only one half of these patients had headaches, and n
o abnormalities were found on neurological examination of many. Diagno
sis was delayed in only four patients with headache caused by a brain
tumor and in three patients with SAHs. Diagnosis was delayed in two of
the latter because of false-negative CT scans. Conclusions. Although
clinical findings and CT scans are not reliable indicators, clinicians
are able to detect the majority of these rare conditions without undu
e delay by selecting a small subset of patients for further investigat
ion. More extensive use of CT scans appears to be a weak strategy to i
mprove detection of these serious disorders, as increased use would le
ad to increased health care costs and unintended adverse effects, and
provide little benefit.