Mp. Noel et X. Seron, ARABIC NUMBER READING DEFICIT - A SINGLE-CASE STUDY OR WHEN 236 IS READ (2306) AND JUDGED SUPERIOR TO 1258, Cognitive neuropsychology, 10(4), 1993, pp. 317-339
This paper presents a single-case study of a patient (NR) showing a ve
ry specific (though not isolated) disorder in Arabic number reading. T
he type of reading errors and the pattern of the results observed in t
asks tapping different components of the number processing system supp
ort the hypothesis of a deficit in the syntactic module of the Arabic
comprehension system (in McCloskey, Sokol, & Goodman's [1986] model).
NR's deficit is also examined in the light of two other number reading
models: Seron and Deloche (1984) and Cohen and Dehaene (1991). In add
ition, the opposition beween semantic and asemantic transcoding models
is discussed. In tasks based on a representation of the quantity, NR'
s errors with Arabic forms seem to result from correct semantic proces
sing based on the expected verbal transcoded forms; this is easily int
erpretable in the semantic transcoding model (e.g. McCloskey et al., 1
986), whereas in asemantic perspectives (e.g. Seron & Deloche, 1984; C
ohen & Dehaene, 1991) no direct explanation is proposed. In this respe
ct, a ''preferred entry code'' hypothesis is developed.