Cl. Perrin et Kb. Armstrong, CONFORMATIONAL-ANALYSIS OF GLUCOPYRANOSYLAMMONIUM IONS - DOES THE REVERSE ANOMERIC EFFECT EXIST, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 115(15), 1993, pp. 6825-6834
Despite the generality of the anomeric effect (the axial tendency exhi
bited by many electronegative groups at Cl of a tetrahydropyran), some
cationic substituents prefer the equatorial position. This preference
is claimed to exceed that due to steric repulsion, and it has been ca
lled a ''reverse anomeric effect''. Such an effect is sometimes invoke
d to account for relative reactivities and stereoselectivities when th
ere are cationic leaving groups. However, all such substituents have b
een bulky aromatic rings whose steric factors are difficult to judge,
and it is advantageous to compare NHR and NH2R+ groups of known axial
preference. Therefore the proportions of axial anomers of glucopyranos
ylamine and some of its N-alkyl, tetra-O-acetyl, and 4,6-benzylidene d
erivatives were determined by H-1 NMR in a variety of solvents, includ
ing acidic media. This proportion is small, and the assignments were c
onfirmed by coupling constants, saturation transfer, reequilibration,
and decoupling difference spectroscopy. The data indicate that the shi
ft in the position of equilibrium that occurs upon N-protonation is sm
all and can be accounted for on the basis of steric effects and a smal
l normal anomeric effect. Therefore we conclude that the reverse anome
ric effect does not exist.