Hp. Wirth et al., TRIAL OF A MODIFIED TRIPLE THERAPY FOR HE LICOBACTER-PYLORI ERADICATION IN RECURRENT DUODENAL-ULCER, Schweizerische medizinische Wochenschrift, 123(35), 1993, pp. 1645-1649
In a prospective trial we examined the efficacy and acceptability of a
modified triple therapy in H. pylori (HP)-positive patients with recu
rrent duodenal ulcer disease. Oral administration of amoxicillin for t
wo weeks was substituted for one single injection of intramuscular dep
ot penicillin (benzathine penicillin G). Additionally, patients were g
iven ornidazole 500 mg tid for 14 days and 120 mg colloidal bismuth su
bcitrate qid for 28 days. The patients were investigated for H. pylori
colonization using a rapid urease test (CLO), histology (H&E-, Giemsa
stain), culture (including determination of the minimal inhibitory con
centrations for metronidazole, penicillin G and amoxicillin) and H. py
lori serology (Cobas Core Anti-H. pylori EIA, F. Hoffmann-La Roche). C
ontrol endoscopies using the same methods were performed 1 and 6 month
s after eradication therapy. The eradication rate was 50% and the ulce
r healing rate 90% 1 month after therapy. Ulcers recurred in 2/3 of pa
tients with persistent infection vs 015 of HP-eradicated patients afte
r 6 months. Both successfully HP-eradicated patients and patients with
treatment failure exhibited comparable decreases in mean serum IgG an
ti-HP concentration within 2 months. Discrimination between the two gr
oups and hence identification of the eradication success by serology w
as not possible within a time period of 2 months. After 6 months, seru
m IgG anti-HP concentrations in non-HP-eradicated patients returned to
pre-therapy values, in HP-eradicated patients the concentrations furt
her decreased. The above-described modified triple therapy against HP
cannot be recommended as a standard therapy, mainly because of the ins
ufficient eradication effect. Occurrence of nitroimidazole resistance,
and insufficient availability and/or activity of parenterally adminis
tered penicillin, seem to be responsible for the rather poor result.