The physical conditions are investigated under which the lithospheric-
scale style of extension is pure shear or simple shear. We focus on th
e initial stages of continental extension to monitor how symmetric or
asymmetric modes of extension evolve from specific tectonic conditions
. Continental collision, magma intrusions and interaction between the
lithosphere and the underlying mantle are investigated as sources for
extension. We use a finite element method to model the thermo-mechanic
al evolution of continental lithosphere. Experimental flow laws are us
ed to model the elastic, brittle, power law creep or diffusion creep r
heology of lithospheric rocks. Our results indicate that if in-plane f
orces change from compressive to tensile immediately after a rapid mou
ntain building phase, initiation of a lithosphere-scale detachment fau
lt is possible. We find a strong dependence of the extensional style o
n the distribution with depth of residual stresses from the collision
phase. This result is consistent with observations of gravitational co
llapse in regions, like the Aegean and the Basin and Range Province, w
here detachment faults have exhumed lower crustal rocks. The predicted
dip direction of the fault also agrees with observations in these are
as. Intrusion of magma into continental lithosphere, which is subject
to in-plane tensile forces, will cause localization of pure shear defo
rmation. The style of deformation resulting from mantle plumes impingi
ng to the base of the lithosphere is symmetric. Delamination of lithos
pheric mantle may initiate detachment faults if delamination occurs at
the end of a collision phase, when in-plane forces change sign from c
ompressive to tensile. This result also strongly depends on the assume
d residual stress distribution. If delamination occurs during the moun
tain building phase, the style of deformation will be pure shear. Anot
her interesting outcome from our modeling is that dramatic strain weak
ening as a result of a deformation mechanism change from dislocation c
reep to diffusion creep, reduces the tendency to strain localization.