A. Schiffrin et al., DIFFERENT RATES OF CONVERSION TO IDDM IN SIBLINGS OF TYPE-1 DIABETIC CHILDREN - THE MONTREAL FAMILY STUDY, Diabetes research and clinical practice, 21(1), 1993, pp. 75-84
This study was undertaken to analyze the risk of developing insulin-de
pendent diabetes (IDDM) in siblings of type 1 diabetic children. Islet
-cell antibodies (ICA) were tested in 568 subjects, siblings of type 1
diabetic children. The subjects were followed prospectively for the c
onversion to clinical diagnosis of IDDM. As a result siblings who were
islet cell antibody (ICA)+ positive at the time of diagnosis of the d
iabetic sibling (index case) had a significantly higher risk of develo
ping IDDM than those who were ICA-. However, of the 19 siblings who de
veloped IDDM, only 10 were ICA+ at the time of the first test but, 17
became ICA+ before diagnosis of IDDM. The interval between a positive
test and the clinical diagnosis of IDDM varied between subjects (6-44
months, mean = 18.4 +/- 4.2 S.E. months) but it was less than 1 year i
n one subject. In addition to the higher risk of developing IDDM when
ICA was positive, male sex and younger age of the subjects as well as
young age of the index case and multiplex pedigrees were significant p
redictors of conversion to IDDM. The Cox's regression tree constructed
using RECPAM identified three groups of varying rates of conversion t
o IDDM: (1) a group with the slowest progression characterized by ICA-
and age of index case > 5 years or female sex (relative hazard = 1);
(2) an intermediate progression group consisting of subjects who are I
CA- and have both < 5 years of age and male sex (relative hazard = 8.7
8); (3) a group with the fastest progression consisting of subjects wh
o are ICA+ (relative hazard = 31.45). From these results our data sugg
est that in addition to ICA, clinical markers such as age, sex and mul
tiple pedigrees are also significant predictors of the rate of convers
ion to IDDM. Furthermore, screening for ICA in family intervention stu
dies will have to be done frequently, perhaps yearly, and will have to
be continued into adult life, particularly in ICA- subjects in order
to identify the 85-90% of subjects who become ICA+ at the clinical dia
gnosis of IDDM.