Conditions on an agent's preferences that induce a demand for ex ante
randomization are derived. When the agent has constant absolute risk a
version in wealth but additive-separable preferences in wealth and eff
ort, optimal contracts often require randomization. Under additive sep
arability, the principal can use randomization to exploit the interact
ion between incentive considerations and the agent's outside opportuni
ties. However, when the agent has constant absolute risk aversion in w
ealth but multiplicative-separable preferences, participation and ince
ntive considerations separate; hence, optimal contracts do not exhibit
ex ante randomization.