Ms. Opsahl et al., THE PREDICTIVE VALUE OF HYSTEROSALPINGOGRAPHY FOR TUBAL AND PERITONEAL INFERTILITY FACTORS, Fertility and sterility, 60(3), 1993, pp. 444-448
Objective: To investigate a practical classification system of hystero
salpingogram (HSG) results that accurately identifies patients with se
vere pelvic disease or a normal pelvis to allow appropriate patient co
unseling of therapeutic options. Design: Retrospective chart review fr
om university teaching hospital. Hysterosalpingography results were cl
assified as normal, abnormal (bilateral distal tubal obstruction), or
suspicious (all others). At surgery, chromopertubation was performed,
and pelvic disease was documented. Results: From a total of 756 patien
ts, HSGs were confirmed surgically in 96.6% of normals, 63.1% of suspi
cious, and 95.7% of abnormal. Associated moderate-severe pelvic diseas
e was found in 16.2% of normals, 53.9% of suspicious, and 81.7% of abn
ormal. Conclusion: Abnormal HSGs are highly predictive of severe pelvi
c disease, and counseling of treatment options does not require diagno
stic laparoscopy. Patients with suspicious HSGs frequently have normal
tubes but also have a significant likelihood of tubal or associated p
elvic disease, and they are responsible for the poor predictive value
of the HSG. This group of patients requires confirmatory laparoscopy p
referably by a physician qualified in pelviscopic surgery. Normal HSGs
have a high negative predictive value. Nevertheless, the incidence of
associated pelvic disease in the normal HSG group is high enough to w
arrant diagnostic laparoscopy if nonsurgical treatment is unsuccessful
.