Ad. Brandon et al., EVALUATING CRUSTAL CONTAMINATION IN CONTINENTAL BASALTS - THE ISOTOPIC COMPOSITION OF THE PICTURE GORGE BASALT OF THE COLUMBIA RIVER BASALTGROUP, Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, 114(4), 1993, pp. 452-464
Crustal contamination of basalts located in the western United States
has been generally under-emphasized, and much of their isotopic variat
ion has been ascribed to multiple and heterogeneous mantle sources. Ba
salts of the Miocene Columbia River Basalt Group in the Pacific Northw
est have passed through crust ranging from Precambrian to Tertiary in
age. These flows are voluminous, homogenous, and underwent rapid effus
ion, all of which are disadvantages for crustal contamination while en
route to the surface. The Picture Gorge Basalt of the Columbia River
Basalt Group erupted through Paleozoic and Mesozoic oceanic accreted t
erranes in central Oregon, and earlier studies on these basalts provid
ed no isotopic evidence for crustal contamination. New Sr, Nd, Pb, and
O isotopic data presented here indicate that the isotopic variation o
f the Picture Gorge Basalt is very small, Sr-87/Sr-86 = 0.70307 - 0.70
371, epsilon(Nd) = +7.7 - +4.8. DeltaO-18 = +5.6 - +6.1, and Pb-206/Pb
-204 = 18.80 - 18.91. Evaluation of the Picture Gorge compositional va
riation supports a model where two isotopic components contributed to
Picture Gorge Basalt genesis. The first component (C1) is reflected by
low Sr-87/Sr-86, high epsilon(Nd), and nonradiogenic Pb isotopic comp
ositions. Basalts with C1 isotopic compositions have large MgO, Ni, an
d Cr contents and mantle-like delta(O-18) = +5.6. C1 basalts have enri
chments in Ba coupled with depletions in Nb and Ta. These characterist
ics are best explained by derivation from a depleted mantle source whi
ch has undergone a recent enrichment by fluids coming from a subducted
slab. This C1 mantle component is prevalent throughout the Pacific No
rthwest. The second isotopic component has higher Sr-87/Sr-86 and delt
aO-18, lower epsilon(Nd), and more radiogenic Pb isotopic compositions
than C1. There is a correlation in the Picture Gorge data of Sr, Nd.
and Pb isotopes with differentiation indicators such as decreasing Mg#
, and increasing K2O/TiO2, Ba, Ba/Zr, Rb/Sr, La/Sm, and La/Yb. Phase e
quilibrium and mineralogical constraints indicate that these compositi
onal characteristics were inherited in the Picture Gorge magmas at cru
stal pressures, and thus the second isotopic component is most likely
crustal in origin. Mixing and open-system calculations can produce the
isotopic composition of the most evolved Picture Gorge flows from the
most primitive compositions by 8 to 21% contamination of isotopic com
positions similar to accreted terrane crust found in the Pacific North
west. Therefore, in spite of the disadvantages for crustal contaminati
on and their narrow range in isotopic compositions, the process contro
lling isotopic variation within the Picture Gorge Basalt is primarily
crustal contamination. We suggest that comprehensive analyses for basa
ltic suites and careful consideration of these data must be made to te
st for crustal contamination, before variation resulting from mantle h
eterogeneity can be assessed.