Pn. Shah et al., MANAGING GERIATRIC SYNDROMES - WHAT GERIATRIC ASSESSMENT TEAMS RECOMMEND, WHAT PRIMARY-CARE PHYSICIANS IMPLEMENT, WHAT PATIENTS ADHERE TO, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 45(4), 1997, pp. 413-419
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the responses of primary care phy---- sicians
and patients to recommendations from a commmunity-based comprehensive
geriatric assessment (CGA) program for management of four target condi
tions: falls, depression, urinary incontinence, and functional impairm
ent. DESIGN: Case series. SETTING: Senior centers, meal sites, senior
housing, and other community sites as screening locations; and a commu
nity-based academic practice as the location for CGA. PARTICIPANTS: A
total of 150 older patients living in the community who have one or mo
re of the four target conditions and who received CGA MEASUREMENTS: Ph
ysician implementation and patient adherence rates were ascertained du
ring a face-to-face structured interview with the patient 3 months aft
er CGA. RESULTS: Two hundred twelve of 528 (40%) CGA recommendations w
ere clearly or possibly related to the target or target-related condit
ions. Of these 212 recommendations, 59% required a physician's order f
or implementation. The remaining 41% were patient self-care recommenda
tions. Overall physician implementation across conditions was 70%; imp
lementation rates were highest for falls and lowest for functional imp
airment. Overall patient adherence rate was 85% for physician-implemen
ted recommendations and 46% for self-care recommendations. Patient adh
erence to recommendations for counseling or support groups and exercis
e programs was particularly low. CONCLUSIONS: When examining the proce
ss of care of community-based CGA, patient as well as physician adhere
nce must be considered. Although patient adherence to physician-initia
ted recommendations was high for all conditions, it varied substantial
ly across target conditions and types of recommendations for self-care
recommendations.