Lg. Rudenko et al., EFFICACY OF LIVE ATTENUATED AND INACTIVATED INFLUENZA VACCINES IN SCHOOLCHILDREN AND THEIR UNVACCINATED CONTACTS IN NOVGOROD, RUSSIA, The Journal of infectious diseases, 168(4), 1993, pp. 881-887
Children aged 7-14 years in Novgorod, Russia, were given Russian live
cold-adapted or inactivated influenza vaccines or placebo over a 2-yea
r period. Schools were randomly assigned as a whole to one of the prep
arations. In the first year, the vaccines were bivalent, containing ty
pes A (H3N2) and A (H1N1) components. In the second year, the vaccines
also contained a type B component. In the first year, all viruses iso
lated were type A (H3N2); in the second, about three-quarters of the i
solates were type B and the rest type A (H1N1). During both years, the
vaccines protected the vaccinated children. Where significant differe
nces existed, the live attenuated vaccine was more protective than the
inactivated. Vaccination rates in schools in which live attenuated va
ccines had been used were inversely related to illness rates of staff
and unvaccinated children, suggesting that viral transmission had been
reduced by the vaccine.