Wt. Cefalu et al., SERUM FRUCTOSAMINE AS A SCREENING-TEST FOR DIABETES IN THE ELDERLY - A PILOT-STUDY, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society, 41(10), 1993, pp. 1090-1094
Objective: To determine the value of serum glycated protein, measured
as serum fructosamine, as a screening test for diabetes in the elderly
. Design: Cross-sectional pilot study. Setting: Ambulatory research cl
inic in university setting. Patients: One hundred fifty-seven consecut
ive community-dwelling participants in the Cardiovascular Health Study
, average age 71.8 + 5 (mean +/- SD, range 65-88 years). Measurements:
Serum fructosamine levels (first and second generation assay) were ob
tained. All subjects who did not have a diagnosis of diabetes were giv
en a 75-g glucose tolerance test (GTT). Results: Twenty-six subjects (
17%) (10 previously diagnosed, 16 undiagnosed and asymptomatic) had di
abetes mellitus, and 38 subjects (24%) had impaired glucose tolerance
by history or by the GTT (WHO criteria). Only the 16 asymptomatic diab
etics were included in the analysis for the pilot study. There was a s
ignificant difference in the fasting fructosamine level between non-di
abetics and asymptomatic diabetics for the first generation (2.06 +/-
.21 vs 2.53 +/- .49 mMol/L, P < 0.0015) and second generation assay (2
21 +/- 27 vs 269 +/- 48 muMol/L, P < 0.0012). Receiver operator curves
were constructed to evaluate the test characteristics of serum fructo
samine. Using a point of greater-than-or-equal-to 2.3 mMol/L for the f
irst-generation assay, the sensitivity to detect asymptomatic diabetes
was 75%, specificity 83%, and positive predictive value 35%. To detec
t both diabetes and impaired glucose tolerance using a cutpoint of gre
ater-than-or-equal-to 2.3 mMol/L, the sensitivity was 24%, specificity
95%, and positive predictive value 68%. Employing a cut point of 250
muMol/L for the second generation assay, the sensitivity to detect dia
betes was 81%, specificity 87%, and positive predictive value 43%. How
ever, to detect diabetes and glucose intolerance using the second gene
ration assay, the sensitivity was 39% and specificity was 86%. Conclus
ion: This study demonstrated that a single measurement of either first
or second generation fructosamine showed promise as a screening test
for diabetes, but not impaired glucose tolerance, in older people.