Sh. Smith et Gi. Whitehead, THE EFFECT OF DYSPHORIA AND PUBLICNESS ON CAUSAL ATTRIBUTIONS, Journal of social behavior and personality, 8(6), 1993, pp. 175-184
The experiment investigated dysphoric and nondepressed people's public
and private attributions for success and failure, Highly dysphoric, m
oderately dysphoric, and nondepressed subjects received favorable or u
nfavorable feedback on an ego-involving social perceptiveness test. Th
ey made attributions to ability, effort, luck and task difficulty whil
e expecting to keep their responses private or discuss them with the e
xperimenter. Highly dysphoric subjects attributed failure more to luck
than did the moderately dysphoric or the nondepressed Highly dysphori
c subjects also rated the test as more accurately assessing their soci
al perceptiveness than did moderately dysphoric or nondepressed subjec
ts. These findings did not replicate those found in Sweeney, Anderson,
and Bailey's (1986) meta-analysis of the literature on attributional
style in depression. Furthermore, subjects receiving unfavorable feedb
ack claimed that the task was more difficult and attributed their perf
ormance more to luck in private than in public. These results replicat
e Smith and Whitehead's (1988) findings and extend them to a dysphoric
sample. Implications of these results are discussed