R. Hehlmann et al., THE GERMAN CML STUDY, COMPARISON OF BUSULFAN VS HYDROXYUREA VS INTERFERON-ALPHA AND ESTABLISHMENT OF PROGNOSTIC SCORE 1, Leukemia & lymphoma, 11, 1993, pp. 159-168
From July 1983 to January 1991 a total of 622 patients were randomized
(585 eligible) to compare the effects of hydroxyurea, interferon alph
a (IFN), and busulfan on the duration of chronic phase, and survival.
Fur-ther goals included the determination of prognostic parameters. 59
8 CML patients were documented and 575 evaluable. The Ph-status was kn
own for 547 patients. 89.4% of the patients were Ph-positive (+). 11 %
had additional chromosome aberrations. The median survival of Ph+ pat
ients by now is 4.2 years, that of Ph-patients 1.4 years. Ph-negative
patients are older, tend to have lower cell counts and, as a group are
more ill at diagnosis. A survival difference of about one year is exp
ected between busulfan, and hydroxyurea treated patients. Prospectivel
y evaluated age, organomegaly related symptoms, Karnofsky index, extra
medullary manifestations, number of erythroblasts and percent of circu
lating blasts proved to be of prognostic significance. A prognostic sc
ore (score 1) was determined which was superior to Sokal's score in th
e study population. 164 patients were randomized to receive IFN. In 54
patients (33%) IFN had to be terminated because of adverse effects, t
herapy resistance or other reasons. Clinically relevant neutralizing a
ntibodies were detected in 9 cases. Most frequent adverse events were
flu-like symptoms in 74%, gastrointestinal symptoms in 52%, and neurol
ogic-psychiatric symptoms in 30% of patients. Reduction of the Ph-chro
mosome was observed in 13% of evaluable patients (10 of 75). In 4 pati
ents complete cytogenetic remissions were observed, in three of these
ongoing. Cytogenetic responders have a survival advantage. Interferon
treated Philadelphia-negative CML patients have no survival disadvanta
ge. The study is expected to allow statements as to the advantages or
disadvantages of the use of busulfan, hydroxyurea and IFN in the treat
ment of CML as well as to the reliability of prognostic markers.