Records of carbon and nitrogen isotopes in biogenic silica and carbon
isotopes in planktonic foraminifera from deep-sea sediment cores from
the Southern Ocean reveal that the primary production during the last
glacial maximum was lower than Holocene productivity. These observatio
ns conflict with the hypothesis that the low atmospheric carbon dioxid
e concentrations were introduced by an increase in the efficiency of t
he high-latitude biological pump. Instead, different oceanic sectors m
ay have had high glacial productivity, or alternative mechanisms that
do not involve the biological pump must be considered as the primary c
ause of the low glacial atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations.