M. Etienne et al., REVERSIBLE MIGRATORY INSERTION BETA-ALKYL ELIMINATION IN ALPHA-AGOSTIC ALKYLNIOBIUM ALKYNE COMPLEXES, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 119(14), 1997, pp. 3218-3228
Ethyl-, n-propyl- and [(trimethylsilyl)methyl]niobium (4e)-alkyne comp
lexes TpNb(Cl)(CH(2)R)(PhC=CR') (Tp* = hydrotris(3,5-dimethylpyrazoly
l)borate; R = Me, R' = Me (2a), Et (2b), n-Pr (2c); R = Et, R' = Me (3
a), Et (3b); R = SiMe(3), R' = Me (4a)) exhibit alpha-agostic structur
es in solution (H-1 and C-13 NMR) and in the solid state (X-ray struct
ure at 173 K for 4a). The phenylpropyne complexes 2a, 3a, and 4a under
go a thermally induced rearrangement which yields niobium methyl compl
exes TpNb(Cl)(Me)(PhC=CEt), Tp*Nb(Cl)(Me)(PhC=C-n-Pr), and Tp*Nb(Cl)(
Me)(PhC=CCH(2)SiMe(3)), respectively. This reaction follows a first-or
der rate law. The rate decreases with increased steric bulk of the alk
yl group in the starting complex. For 2a, a full kinetic analysis yiel
ds a high enthalpic barrier and an entropy of activation close to zero
. Heating a toluene solution of TpNb(Cl)(n-Pr)-(PhC=CEt) (3b) establi
shes a 1:1 equilibrium between 3b itself and TpNb(Cl)(Et)(PhC=C-n-Pr)
(2c). Heating a solution of TpNb(Cl)(Et)(PhC=CEt) (2b) and PhC=CMe y
ields the eta(1)-alkenyl (4e)-phenylpropyne complex TpNb(Cl)(eta(1)-C
Ph=CEt(2))(PhC=CMe) (6), demonstrating that alkyl migration is a key s
tep of the rearrangement. Under pseudo-first-order conditions, this re
action does not depend on the phenylpropyne concentration. Potential 2
e-donor ligands fail to act as efficient traps. Accordingly, a success
ful trapping experiment involves dinitrogen extrusion from N3P(N-i-Pr-
2)(2) in the presence of 2b which yields an unprecedented (phosphinoim
ido)niobium complex: TpNb(Cl)(eta(1)-CPh=CEt(2))[=N-P(N-i-Pr-2)(2)] (
7) The crystal structure of 7 confirms the eta(1)-alkenyl formulation
and reveals a formal Nb-N triple bond, a linear Nb-N-P link, and a pyr
amidal P. Deoxygenation of propene oxide and desulfurization of ethyle
ne sulfide gives, respectively, the oxo and sulfide eta(1)-alkenyl com
plexes TpNb(Cl)(eta(1)-CPh=CEt(2))(=X) (X = 0 (8), S (9)). The observ
ed thermal rearrangements are unique examples of reversible migratory
insertion/beta-alkyl elimination in transition metal alkyl alkyne comp
lexes. In the absence of efficient trapping agent, the unsaturated eta
(2)-alkenyl intermediate that is first generated reversibly ring opens
and ring closes. This realizes the intramolecular C-C bond activation
which leads to the observed alkyl switch. Kinetic and trapping data i
ndicate that the migratory insertion of the alkyl group on to the alky
ne is the rate-determining step of the whole process.