J. Bybee et al., THE FANTASY, IDEAL, AND OUGHT SELVES - CONTENT, RELATIONSHIPS TO MENTAL-HEALTH, AND FUNCTIONS, Social cognition, 15(1), 1997, pp. 37-53
The present study explored the fantasy self, a previously neglected co
nstruct, and complemented work documenting maladaptive mental health c
orrelates of actual-ought discrepancy by tying the ought self to proso
cial and achievement-oriented behaviors. To distinguish and identify d
efining aspects of the fantasy, ideal, and ought selves, content analy
ses were used in Study 1 to examine 81 participants' possible self-des
criptions. In Study 2, personality and behavioral correlates of each s
elf-image type were identified using peer and self reports from 74 par
ticipants. The fantasy self contained desires for celebrity, wealth, p
ower, travel, and magical abilities. Those preoccupied with their fant
asy self were antisocial and nonconformists, scoring low on conscienti
ousness, social competence, and academic performance. The ideal self-i
mage contained self-centered aspirations (e.g., career success, autono
my, popularity, intelligence). Participants' preoccupation with their
ideal self was correlated with anxiety, self-consciousness, and vulner
ability. The ought self contained desires to be caring, honest, hard-w
orking, responsible, and ethical. Individuals preoccupied with these o
bligations were more altruistic, warm, and achievement-oriented.