Df. Hay et al., Young children's quarrels with their siblings and mothers: Links with maternal depression and bipolar illness, BR J DEV PS, 16, 1998, pp. 519-538
Patterns of conflict amongst a mother and two young children were recorded
for 55 families in the US. The mother was well in 19 families, depressed in
20, and had bipolar illness in 16. Sibling conflict occurred least often w
hen the mother had bipolar illness. Mother-child conflict occurred most oft
en when the elder child was male, but depressed mothers were likely to quar
rel with their elder daughters. Mothers allied with elder rather than young
er children, but depressed mothers were especially likely to uphold the rig
hts of protesters. Compensatory influence was noted across relationships, s
o that children whose actions were protested by mothers were less likely to
object to the behaviour of their siblings. In general, when mothers were w
ell, families experienced frequent, but mild conflict; when mothers had bip
olar illness, the relationship between the mother and the elder son was esp
ecially fraught; and when mothers were depressed, conflicts were more likel
y to escalate and to occur between mothers and daughters.