Mg. Choi et al., [C-13]OCTANOIC ACID BREATH TEST FOR GASTRIC-EMPTYING OF SOLIDS - ACCURACY, REPRODUCIBILITY, AND COMPARISON WITH SCINTIGRAPHY, Gastroenterology, 112(4), 1997, pp. 1155-1162
Background & Aims: Previous work suggested that a breath test using C-
13 accurately measures gastric emptying of solids. Thus, breath test h
alf emptying time (t(1/2)) minus 66 minutes was claimed to estimate ac
curately t(1/2) by scintigraphy. The aim of this study was to evaluate
the accuracy and reproducibility of this breath test in healthy subje
cts. Methods: Fifteen volunteers (8 men and 7 women; mean age, 41 +/-
13 years) underwent simultaneous scintigraphy and [C-13]octanoic acid
breath test. Scans and breath samples were obtained every 15 minutes f
or 4 and 6 hours, respectively. The breath test was repeated three tim
es within a 3-week period. Results: Parameters from scintigraphy and b
reath test were not correlated significantly. Differences of lag phase
and t(1/2) between the two tests were highly variable (range for t(1/
2), -33.1 to 169.6; mean, 48.0 minutes). Increasing breath test ''dura
tion'' (samples over 4, 5, or 6 hours) yielded decreasing estimates of
the lag phase and t(1/2) Although widely different values were observ
ed in some subjects, repeated breath tests showed a high degree of rep
roducibility within individuals (mean coefficient of variation, 12%).
Conclusion: [C-13]Octanoic acid breath test for gastric emptying of so
lids requires further validation before it can substitute for scintigr
aphy as a diagnostic test, but it seems useful for intraindividual com
parisons.