I. Vallverdu et al., Clinical characteristics, respiratory functional parameters, and outcome of a two-hour T-piece trial in patients weaning from mechanical ventilation, AM J R CRIT, 158(6), 1998, pp. 1855-1862
The discrepancy in results from different studies regarding outcome of wean
ing from mechanical ventilation may be due to several factors such as the d
ifferences in patient populations and weaning indexes used. In order to ana
lyze the clinical characteristics and weaning Indexes in patients undergoin
g a 2-h T-piece weaning trial and the relationship between the etiology of
acute respiratory failure (ARF) and the outcome of this weaning trial, we p
rospectively studied 217 patients receiving mechanical ventilation who met
standard weaning criteria. Successful weaning occurred In 57.6% (125 of 217
) of patients: 13 of 33 (39.4%) patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease (COPD), 27 of 46 (58.7%) neurologic patients, and 85 of 138 (61.6%
) patients with ARF. Ventilatory support was reinstituted in 31.8% (69 of 2
17) patients: 20 of 33 (60.6%) of patients with COPD, four of 46 (8.7%) neu
rologic patients, and 45 of 138 (32.6%) patients with ARF (p < 0.001). Rein
tubation was required in 23 of 148 (15.5%) patients: 15 of 42 (35.7%) neuro
logic patients, and eight of 93 (8.6%) patients with ARF, whereas no patien
t with COPD was reintubated (p < 0.001). Using a discriminant analysis, the
following variables were selected as the best predictors of outcome: (1) I
n the whole population, days of mechanical ventilation before weaning trial
(DMV), frequency-to-tidal volume ratio (f/VT), maximal inspiratory pressur
e (MIP), airway occlusion pressure (P-0.1), maximal expiratory pressure (ME
P), and vital capacity (VC); (2) in patients with ARF, DMV, P-0.1/MIP, MIP,
f/VT, and age; (3) in patients with COPD, f/VT, P-0.1, P-0.1/MIP, MIP, age
, and DMV; (4) in neurologic patients, MIP, MEP, and f/VT P-0.1. Using thes
e predictors, 74.6% of the whole population, 76.1% of patients with ARF, 93
.9% of patients with COPD, and 73.9% of neurologic patients were accurately
classified as weaning successes or failures. The highest rate of reintubat
ion occurred in neurologic patients. In this group, the ability to cough an
d clear respiratory secretions, objectively reflected by MEP, may help in c
linical decision-making.