The assumptions which guarantee convergence of EAS elements first introduce
d by Simo and Rifai, can be reduced to two postulates. Specifically, the st
ability condition refers to a relaxed stability of an associated Hu-Washizu
principle. We investigate the problem of volume locking of membrane proble
ms. Estimates of a certain type which for instance imply Volume locking of
the Q1-element, are fortunately not present with EAS elements. Finally we v
erify an equivalence of the EAS concept with a Hellinger-Reissner method wh
ich was observed in numerical computations by Andelfinger and Ramm. (C) 199
8 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.