Recent articles in the scientific literature and popular press have argued
for federal protection for prairie dogs (Cynomys ludovicianus) based on the
ir role as a keystone species in North American grasslands. A critical eval
uation of published studies, however reveals that our knowledge of the effe
cts of prairie dogs on other animals may be more limited and equivocal than
these articles suggest. Moreover, differences in responses to grazing and
disturbance of the types of grasslands inhabited by prairie dogs suggest th
at prairie dogs may affect the vegetation and fauna of these systems differ
ently, yet we know little about their ecological role in many grasslands. F
uture research may provide convincing evidence that prairie dogs have dispr
oportionately large, unique effects on prairie ecosystems, but it may be pr
emature to characterize prairie dogs as keystone species in grasslands thro
ughout the Great Plains. Despite decades of interest in and study of the ef
fects of this conspicuous and influential species, large gaps in our knowle
dge of the ecology of prairie clogs persist and warrant additional research
.