Objective: To compare Karman cannula aspiration followed by dissecting micr
oscopy with suction curettage and permanent histology in obtaining and iden
tifying chorionic villi. Methods: Karman cannula aspiration was performed b
efore standard curettage for failed intrauterine pregnancies (N = 22) or po
ssible ectopic gestation (N = 24). Dissection microscopy for chorionic vill
i was performed on aspirates before submission for permanent histology. Sen
sitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive value of each metho
d in obtaining and identifying villi was determined. Results: Overall, all
methods were only moderately sensitive in detecting chorionic villi (50-76%
). If failed intrauterine pregnancies were excluded, all methods had poor s
ensitivity (25-64%). However, if villi were detected, the positive predicti
ve value of all methods was high (> 80%). Conclusions: Karman cannula aspir
ation followed by dissecting microscope examination or permanent histology
may offer an alternative to traditional curettage in the diagnosis of ectop
ic gestations. A larger trial to validate these findings seems justified. (
C) 1998 International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics.