Gs. Duane et Ja. Curry, ENTROPY OF A CONVECTING WATER-AIR SYSTEM AND THE INTERPRETATION OF CLOUD MORPHOGENESIS, Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society, 123(539), 1997, pp. 605-629
Cloud-top entrainment in the stratocumulus-to-cumulus transition can b
e viewed as an entropy-decreasing, self-organizing process. An express
ion is derived for the entropy of a two-phase convecting water-air sys
tem which locates the entropy deficit in the region of the convection
itself, generalizing a similar formulation of Button's for the one-com
ponent case. This expression is applied to a buoyancy-reversal model t
hat simulates entrainment through convection driven by evaporative coo
ling. The overall entropy budget suggests that the evaporation/precipi
tation cycle is an essential ingredient of the stratocumulus-to-cumulu
s transition, underlying the difference between the behaviour of this
system and that of the buoyancy-reversal system. The cumulus cloud sys
tem is thus rendered as a dissipative structure. The class of dynamica
l mechanisms that can explain the stratocumulus-to-cumulus transition,
together with the associated high entrainment rates, is restricted to
those which depend on the water cycle. The relocalized entropy expres
sion, in conjunction with the second law of thermodynamics, implies an
upper bound on the possible extent of change in cloud form for given
flux of water substance through the evaporation/precipitation cycle ov
er the history of cloud morphogenesis.