Statement of problem, Antimicrobial mouthrinses have become an important pa
rt of comprehensive dental care. However, mouthrinses that contain alcohol
have been shown to be detrimental to patients undergoing radiation therapy
for head and neck cancer, to some immunocompromised patients, to families w
ith small children, and to persons sensitive to alcohol.
Purpose. This study evaluated the effectiveness of alcohol-free, 0.12% chlo
rhexidine mouthrinse in reducing microbial levels when compared with commer
cially available 0.12% chlorhexidine (CHX) and essential oils mouthrinses.
Material and methods. This study consisted of both in vitro and in vivo inv
estigations. The double-blind study included 32 subjects randomly assigned
to 3 groups, equalized according to the indices tested. One group (n = 11)
received essential oils rinse; the second group (n = 11) received CHX; and
the last group (n = 10) received the alcohol-free CHS. Subjects mere asked
not to use any mechanical means of oral hygiene for 21 days. The in vitro p
art of the study consisted of Streptococcus mutans strip tests.
Results. Mean plaque scores for both CHX products decreased after 21 days,
whereas the mean for the essential oils increased. Bleeding and gingival in
dex scores for all 3 groups increased, which may be due to the initially he
althy tissues of the participants. Relative microbial growth for S mutans f
or both the CHS products decreased to 0 after 21 days, whereas the counts f
or the essential oils group remained varied.