Young infants have an impressive knowledge of material objects. They apprec
iate that distinct objects cannot occupy the same space at the same time, a
re internally cohesive units that maintain their boundaries, and exist cont
inuously in space and time. We report a surprising limit to this body of un
derstanding: Although 8-month-olds responded to the "magical" disappearance
of an object as an unexpected event, they did not so respond to a magical
appearance. These results suggest that infants' understanding of objects di
ffers from adult cognition in important respects. We discuss Sour possible
ways in which this finding can be reconciled with evidence that infants app
reciate the spatiotemporal continuity of objects.