Sw. Poulton et al., Porewater sulphur geochemistry and fossil preservation during phosphate diagenesis in a Lower Cretaceous shelf mudstone, SEDIMENTOL, 45(5), 1998, pp. 875-887
Lower Cretaceous mudstones exposed at Speeton in North Yorkshire, UK, conta
in lobsters and burrows preserved in diagenetic phosphate concretions. Isot
opic compositions of sulphur in both diagenetic sulphide and structural sul
phate in diagenetic phosphate have been measured in an attempt to constrain
diagenetic porewater chemistry. The occurrence of phosphatized and pyritiz
ed lobsters and similarly preserved burrows, allows a detailed comparison o
f these microenvironments with the host sediments. Host sediments are exten
sively bioturbated and characterized by very light sulphide isotopic compos
itions (mean sulphide delta(34)S = -48.3 +/- 3 parts per thousand (1 sigma,
n = 19)) and sulphate isotopic compositions that are lighter than Lower Cr
etaceous seawater sulphate (mean sulphate delta(34)S = +8.7 +/- 3.2 parts p
er thousand (1 sigma, n = 19)). These isotopic values can be explained by t
he action of bioturbating macrofauna; the introduction of oxygen in ventila
ting seawater results in the oxidation of early formed isotopically light p
yrite, resulting in porewater sulphate that is enriched in S-32. Subsequent
pyrite formation via bacteriogenic reduction of isotopically light porewat
er sulphate leads to the formation of isotopically light pyrite, whilst res
idual porewater sulphate apparently remains relatively enriched in the 32S
isotope. Sulphur isotopic values for the burrows are very different; sulphi
de isotopic compositions average -34.4 +/- 0.4 parts per thousand (1 sigma,
n = 3) and sulphate isotopic compositions average -14.4 +/- 6.6 parts per
thousand (1 sigma, n = 4). These isotopic compositions are the result of ra
pid development of closed system conditions in burrows, resulting in the bu
ild-up of acidity necessary for phosphate precipitation and coprecipitation
of isotopically light sulphate (formed by oxidation of isotopically light
sulphide surrounding the burrows). Lobster shell isotopic compositions fall
between these two groups. On the basis of their isotopic compositions, som
e lobsters appear to have died close to the sediment-water interface, whils
t others appear to have been buried (in burrows) prior to death.