Rm. Gillies et Af. Ashman, Behavior and interactions of children in cooperative groups in lower and middle elementary grades, J EDUC PSYC, 90(4), 1998, pp. 746-757
The study investigated the behaviors and interactions of children in struct
ured and unstructured groups as they worked together on a 6-week social stu
dies activity each term for 3 school terms. Two hundred and twelve children
in Grade 1 and 184 children in Grade 3 participated in the study. Stratifi
ed random assignment occurred so that each gender-balanced group consisted
of 1 high-, 2 medium-, and 1 low-ability student. The results show that the
children in the structured groups were consistently more cooperative and t
hey provided more elaborated and nonelaborated help than did their peers in
the unstructured groups. The children in the structured groups in Grade 3
obtained higher reading and learning outcome scores than their peers in the
unstructured groups.