Neonate Crusoes, the private language argument and psychology

Citation
D. Walton et Kt. Strongman, Neonate Crusoes, the private language argument and psychology, PHILOS PSYC, 11(4), 1998, pp. 443-465
Citations number
44
Categorie Soggetti
Psycology
Journal title
PHILOSOPHICAL PSYCHOLOGY
ISSN journal
09515089 → ACNP
Volume
11
Issue
4
Year of publication
1998
Pages
443 - 465
Database
ISI
SICI code
0951-5089(199812)11:4<443:NCTPLA>2.0.ZU;2-6
Abstract
This article questions social constructionists' claims to introduce Wittgen stein's philosophy to psychology. The philosophical fiction of a neonate Cr usoe is introduced to cast doubt oil the interpretations and use of the pri vate language argument to support a new psychology developed by the constru ctionists. It is argued that a neonate Crusoe's viability in philosophy and apparent absence ill psychology offends against the integrity of the philo sophical contribution Wittgenstein might make to psychology. The consequenc es of accepting Crusoe's viability are explored as they appear in both phil osophy and psychology.