The effect of annually switching sward management between cutting regi
mes that simulated rotational grazing and those for forage conservatio
n vs. maintaining a constant management regime was studied by testing
for ranking-order changes between six perennial ryegrass varieties. To
tal dry-matter (DM) yields were found to change in response to an annu
al switch in management. When under a conservation management and swit
ched in the next year to simulated grazing, all six varieties yielded
more in that year than when they were maintained constantly under simu
lated grazing. Similarly, when under a simulated grazing management an
d switched in the next year to conservation, all six varieties yielded
less than when maintained constantly under a conservation management.
These yield differences were largely expressed in spring of the year
following the management switch. Differences in the ranking order of v
arieties were observed between the constant sward management treatment
s and the alternating managements. However, in these changes in variet
y ranking, no variety was consistently favoured or disadvantaged by th
e annual switch in management. Therefore, no clear evidence was produc
ed that an alternating management system had any consistent effect on
variety ranking and the observed changes were possibly due to the norm
al year-to-year variation frequently recorded in variety performance t
rials.