The standard static-ion impact electron theory of line broadening is assess
ed with a calculation of the He II P-alpha line over a broad range of plasm
a conditions. Ion dynamics, an improved electron collision operator, and ac
curate atomic physics are included in the computation. Simulations also hav
e been performed to validate effects included in the calculation at higher
densities. Calculated linewidths are compared with experiment over more tha
n two decades in electron density, and broad agreement is found. This provi
des the first critical evaluation of the assumptions of Stark broadening th
eory. The profiles also display the first unambiguous evidence of ion dynam
ics.