Immunohistochemical analysis of mechanoreceptors in the human posterior cruciate ligament - A demonstration of its proprioceptive role and clinical relevance
Me. Del Valle et al., Immunohistochemical analysis of mechanoreceptors in the human posterior cruciate ligament - A demonstration of its proprioceptive role and clinical relevance, J ARTHROPLA, 13(8), 1998, pp. 916-922
Although long-term studies report successful results with total knee arthro
plasty (TKA), performed with or without posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) r
etention, controversy exists as to which is preferable in regard to patient
outcome and satisfaction. The possible proprioceptive role of the PCL may
account for a more normal feeling of the arthroplasty. Although the PCL has
been examined using various histological techniques, immunohistochemical t
echniques are the most sensitive for neural elements. Therefore an immunohi
stochemical study was designed to determine the patterns of innervation, th
e morphological types of the proprioceptors, and their immunohistochemical
profile. During TKA, samples were obtained from 22 osteoarthritic PCLs and
subjected to immunohistochemical analysis with mouse monoclonal antibodies
against neurofilament protein (NFP), S100 protein (S100P), epithelial membr
ane antigen (EMA), and vimentin (all present in neuromechanoreceptors). Thr
ee normal PCLs from cadaveric specimens were also obtained and analyzed for
comparison. Five types of sensory corpuscles were observed in both the nor
mal and the arthritic PCLs: simple lamellar, Pacini-like, Ruffini, Krause-l
ike, and morphologically unclassified. Their structure included a central a
xon, inner core, and capsule in lamellar and Pacini corpuscles and variable
intracorpuscular axons and periaxonal cells in the Ruffini and Krause-like
corpuscles. The immunohistochemical profile showed the central axon to hav
e NFP immunoreactivity, periaxonal cells to have S100P and vimentin immunor
eactivity, and the capsule to have EMA and vimentin immunoreactivity. Nerve
fibers and free nerve endings displayed NFP and S100P immunoreactivity. Th
e immunohistochemical profile of the PCL sensory corpuscles is almost ident
ical to that of cutaneous sensory corpuscles. Some prior histological studi
es of the PCL reported Golgi-like mechanoreceptors, and others found encaps
ulated corpuscles but no Golgi-like structures. This report determined the
innervation of the PCL by the more sensitive immunohistochemical means, rev
ealing four major types of encapsulated mechanoreceptors. The plentiful and
varied types of encapsulated mechanoreceptors found in even the arthritic
PCL suggests a rich proprioceptive role. It is controversial as to whether
preservation of the PCL at TKA improves postoperative proprioception. Our f
indings tend to support those clinical reports of improved proprioception a
fter PCL-retaining versus PCL-substituting TKAs. The presence of many and v
aried types of mechanoreceptors may account for the improved stair climbing
reported in patients with PCL-retaining TKA and may contribute to patient
satisfaction and a more normal feeling after TKA.