The N-H tautomerism of free base porphyrin is investigated at the semi
empirical spin-unrestricted AM1 (UAM1) and ab initio RHF/3-21G levels.
The UAM1 method provides delocalized geometries for all stationary st
ructures without imposing any symmetry constraint. RHF/3-21G geometry
optimizations have to be performed under symmetry restrictions to ensu
re that realistic delocalized structures are obtained. Both the semiem
pirical and the ab initio calculations predict that the interconversio
n between trans tautomers proceeds in an asynchronous two-step process
via intermediate cis tautomers. The cis tautomers are characterized a
s minima in the potential energy surface and are 8-10 kcal mol(-1) hig
her in energy. The activation energy for the trans --> cia interconver
sion is calculated to be approximately 23 kcal mol(-1) at the 3-21G le
vel. The activation energy for the synchronous trans --> trans interco
nversion is higher and has a value of 30.5 kcal mol(-1). The activatio
n energies obtained at the semiempirical UAM1 level are twice as large
as the ab initio values.