Long-term lymphoblastoid interferon-alpha therapy for non-cirrhotic chronic hepatitis C: An Italian multicentre study on dose and duration of LFN alpha treatment
F. Piccinino et al., Long-term lymphoblastoid interferon-alpha therapy for non-cirrhotic chronic hepatitis C: An Italian multicentre study on dose and duration of LFN alpha treatment, RES VIROL, 149(5), 1998, pp. 283-291
The aims of the study were to evaluate the long-term efficacy and tolerabil
ity of different doses of interferon-alpha (IFN alpha) and different durati
ons of treatment in chronic hepatitis C by comparing 3 or 6 mega units (MUs
) three times weekly given for either 12 or 24 months, and the possibility
of obtaining a response in non-responder patients by increasing the dose or
by administering IFN dairy. A total of 504 patients with non-cirrhotic chr
onic hepatitis C enrolled in a multicentre study were consecutively assigne
d to receive either 3 (255 patients) or 6 MU (249 patients) of lymphoblasto
id IFNa 3 times a week (tiw). At the 12th month of therapy, patients with n
ormal aminotransferase (AMT) in both groups were either given IFN for an ad
ditional 12 months with an unmodified or halved dose, or else discontinued
therapy. For patients with unmodified AMT levels after 6 months of therapy,
the IFN dose was doubled in the 3-MU group, while it was administered at 3
MU daily in the 6-MU group. When no improvement was achieved, therapy was
discontinued; otherwise it was prolonged until the 18th month. Patients wer
e followed up for 12 months after discontinuing IFN. Of the 255 patients en
rolled at 3 MU, therapy was stopped during the first 6 months in 36 patient
s (14.1%) because of side effects, and in 24 (9.4%) because of lack of coop
eration. Of the remaining 195 patients at the 6th month of therapy, 119 (61
%) had normal and 76 (39%) unmodified AMT levels; 14 of the 76 normalized A
MT after doubting the dose of IFN, but only 5 (6.6%) had a sustained respon
se. Of the 119 patients with normal AMT, 40 discontinued IFN at the 12th mo
nth (schedule A), 39 remained at 3 MU tiw (schedule B) and 40 were given a
dose of 1.5 MU tiw (schedule C) for an additional 12 months. At the end of
follow-up, 23/40 (57.5%) patients in schedule A, 31/39 (79.5%) on schedule
B and 29/40 (72.5%) on schedule C still had normal AMT (A vs. B p = 0.04).
In an intention-to-treat analysis, the sustained response rate for patients
enrolled at 3 MUs, including the 5 initial non-responders, was 34.5%. Of t
he 249 patients enrolled at 6 MU, therapy was discontinued during the first
6 months for 39 (15.7%) because of side effects, and for 27 (10.8%) becaus
e of lack of cooperation. Of the remaining 183 patients at the 6th month of
therapy, 110 (60%) had normal and 73 (40%) unmodified AMT levels. Of the 7
3 patients, 55 accepted the daily regimen and 8 of them (14.5%) showed a su
stained response. Of the 110 patients with normal AMT, 32 (29.1%), despite
normalization of AMT, spontaneously discontinued IFN or reduced the dose be
cause of a poor quality of life, while 78 continued with 6 MU until the 12t
h month, when therapy was discontinued for 28 (schedule Al); 24 patients we
re given an unmodified dose (schedule B1) and 26 a halved dose (schedule C1
) for an additional 12 months. At the end of follow-up, 18/28 (64.3%) patie
nts on schedule Al, 19/24 (79.2%) on schedule B1 and 19/26 (73.1%) on C1 st
ill had normal AMT (p = NS). In an intention-to-treat evaluation, the susta
ined response rate for patients enrolled at 6 MU, including the 8 from the
daily treatment, was 25.7% (64/249). HCV viraemia was undetectable 1 year a
fter discontinuation of IFN in 72.6% of patients with a sustained response.
Sustained response was observed in 36.4% of patients with minimal, 46.6% o
f those with mild, and 33.3% with moderate or severe histological activity
(p = NS). The rate of sustained response was lower in patients with genotyp
e Ib (23.6%) than in those with genotype 2a (67.8%, p = 0.002) or genotype
3 (50%, p = 0.03), irrespective of the histological activity.
In conclusion, 6 MU IFN alpha are no more effective than 3 MU in inducing a
sustained response in treatments of both 12 and 24 months. A 24-month trea
tment is more effective than a 12-month treatment in maintaining a biochemi
cal response after discontinuation of IFN. In terms of efficacy, compliance
and cost, 3 MU for 24 months appears to be the best treatment schedule. Th
e benefit of doubling the dose of IFN for the 3 MU non-responders is slight
, while the daily administration of 3 MU IFN seems to be more effective.