A. Benzing, How to treat one's mother - Considerations about the relationship between man and environment in the Andes, TROPENLANDW, 99(2), 1998, pp. 111-124
Throughout nearly 10,000 years, Andean peoples created an agricultural civi
lization that was able to respond adequately to most constraints that an ex
tremely difficult natural environment imposed on them. Despite the destruct
ion of original political (macro)systems by colonization, a good deal of th
eir tradition and knowledge has survived until our days. Rituals related to
"mother earth" still play an important role. For this reason several Europ
ean and Andean authors consider that indigenous Andean farmers live in harm
ony with nature, and especially with agricultural soil. On the other hand,
ecosystem destruction, with soil erosion as a major problem, is obvious all
over the Andes. The author argues that indigenous peoples, since they depe
nd in a very direct form on nature's productivity, can not conceive nature
as a value per se. Only a productive landscape is "beautiful" from their po
int of view. Ecologically well adapted traditional agricultural techniques
have developed through a long process of trial and error. If they were the
result of an attitude of respect towards nature, peasants would be able, or
at least trying to find ecologically sound responses to changing condition
s, as e.g. population growth. This, obviously, is not the case. It is sugge
sted that "mother earth" does not refer to soil, but to a female deity that
gives fertility to soil. To achieve its good will, rituals are required, b
ut not terraces, manuring or crop rotations. To promote sustainable agricul
tural practices, ecological or historical arguments seem to be very week. O
nly direct economic benefit from this kind of practice will be convincing f
or farmers.