Academic and political debate regarding the desirability of metropolitan go
vernment has focused on the provision of public goods. Although efficient p
roduction of services is of great importance, the consequences of metropoli
tan government for economic development have remained unexplored. The autho
rs assess the development impacts of city-county consolidation by examining
the attraction of manufacturing and retail/service firms for nine consolid
ated governments from 1950 to 1993. The annual growth in manufacturing, ret
ail, and service establishments in the county before the merger is compared
to the record afterward. No support emerges for the idea that consolidatio
n enhances economic development.