Background: Information on which strategies have been shown to be effective
, which are ineffective, and which strategies have been inadequately evalua
ted is important for both public policy and future research.
Objective: To provide systematic reviews of the literature on important str
ategies to prevent motor vehicle injuries.
Methods: The Injury Control Research Centers (ICRCs) funded by the Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention identified 9 important motor vehicle inj
ury prevention strategies. A systematic review of the literature in 9 diffe
rent computerized databases was conducted to identify relevant controlled t
rials. These were critically reviewed and summarized.
Results: A total of 54,078 citations were reviewed; 1,111 met initial scree
ning criteria. The reports for these citations were obtained and critically
reviewed by the ICRCs. Standard criteria for inclusion of articles in the
review and for evaluating the methodological quality of the articles were a
pplied. Few randomized controlled trials were found; most controlled studie
s were either comparisons over time and/or across different populations. Ne
vertheless, these studies were able to be summarized to provide meaningful
conclusions about the effectiveness of various interventions to decrease mo
rbidity and mortality from motor vehicle crashes.
Conclusions: A large body of literature on motor vehicle injury interventio
ns exists. The summary of this literature will provide useful information t
o direct policy and future research efforts.