Critics of industrial agriculture and advocates of ecological agricult
ure have cited Amish farming as a model of stewardship and sustainabil
ity. Amish farming in St. Lawrence County, New York, embodied ecologic
al agriculture in some respects but not others. In comparison with non
-Amish neighbors, Amish farms were smaller in scale, more diverse, and
less integrated into the market economy. On the other hand, use of fe
rtilizers and pesticides for crop production appeared to differ in kin
d, nor amount. Amish farmers relied primarily on their own experience,
not trade magazines or the local cooperative extension, for agricultu
ral information. The high use of petroleum-based inputs may have refle
cted the newness of Amish settlement in St. Lawrence County, a lack of
awareness of the ecological impacts of these substances, or a shift a
way from traditional practices. In the self-sufficiency of their lives
based on subsistence and diversity, these Amish otherwise exemplified
the productive and self-regulatory characteristics of ecological agri
culture.