Forensic identification with imperfect evidence

Citation
Ap. Dawid et J. Mortera, Forensic identification with imperfect evidence, BIOMETRIKA, 85(4), 1998, pp. 835-849
Citations number
18
Categorie Soggetti
Biology,Multidisciplinary,Mathematics
Journal title
BIOMETRIKA
ISSN journal
00063444 → ACNP
Volume
85
Issue
4
Year of publication
1998
Pages
835 - 849
Database
ISI
SICI code
0006-3444(199812)85:4<835:FIWIE>2.0.ZU;2-9
Abstract
We study the problem of forensic identification when the trace evidence fro m the scene of the crime is imperfect: for example, it might be measured wi th error, or be partially missing. A general framework for imperfect data i s developed, and applied in particular to the following cases, singly and i n combination: 'measurement error' in the recorded information at the scene of the crime;'binning', i.e. discretisation of an originally continuous cr ime measurement; 'paternity testing', in which the DNA profiles of the chil d and of the mother provide partial information on the true father's DNA; t wo types of 'laboratory error', one in which the error is equally distribut ed among all possible results, and a second in which there is a bias in the error mechanism producing a false match; and 'partial data', as when there is information on the offender's DNA profile, but not on his racial group.