Ej. Feleppa et al., Advanced two-dimensional and three-dimensional ultrasonic imaging of the prostate for detecting, evaluating, and monitoring cancer, MOL UROL, 2(3), 1998, pp. 229-235
Transrectal biopsies of the prostate are guided using B-mode ultrasound. Ab
out 30% of initial biopsies in men suspected of having prostate cancer are
positive. A slightly lower incidence of positive biopsies occurs in repeat
examinations of men having negative initial biopsies. These rates of detect
ion imply that the sensitivity of conventional ultrasound-guided procedures
is between 40% and 50%. With about 330,000 new cases of prostate cancer de
tected annually in the US, these figures suggest that more than 600,000 act
ually positive glands are biopsied at least once, and that even with repeat
biopsies, almost 300,000 cancers go undetected; i.e., produce false-negati
ve results. The figures also suggest that well over 1,000,000 biopsy examin
ations are performed annually, which indicates that the biopsies of about 4
00,000 men produce true-negative results and hence, in hindsight, were unne
cessary. We have acquired ultrasonic and biopsy data from more than 250 pat
ients. We have compared the classification efficacy of spectrum analysis of
the radiofrequency (RF) echo signals (present, but not utilized, in conven
tional ultrasound instruments) with B-mode imaging currently used for biops
y guidance. Our latest comparison of spectrum-analysis results with B-mode
image-interpretation data from 96 patients and 448 biopsies produced relati
ve operating characteristic (ROC) curve areas of 0.75 for spectrum analysis
and 0.58 for B-mode biopsy guidance; the gold standard for these compariso
ns was the histology findings of the 448 biopsies. Our results indicate tha
t biopsy guidance based on spectrum analysis can improve sensitivity and ca
ncer detection by approximately 50%; i.e., increasing the number of cancers
detected annually in the US to more than 450,000. Similarly, spectrum anal
ysis potentially can aid in evaluating and monitoring detected cancers by h
elping to assess the number, location, and volume of lesions and by providi
ng a quantitative means of determining the nature and rate of change in les
ion properties. Obvious applications are guiding therapy (brachytherapy, cr
yotherapy, etc.), determining whether surgery is warranted, assisting in wa
tchful waiting, titrating treatment, and assessing responses to neoadjuvant
therapy. Spectral methods can be incorporated into clinically useful image
s. Such images are digitally generated from RF signals by computing spectra
at each pixel location. Pixel values in the resulting image may depict spe
ctral parameters, tissue properties (such as scatterer sizes or concentrati
ons), or on the basis of comparisons with database values, either most like
ly tissue type or level of suspicion (LOS). Either two- or three-dimensiona
l presentations can be generated; 3D renderings can be formed from sets of
component 2D images. In 2D, any of these formats, but particularly the LOS
format, could be used for more effective biopsy guidance; in two- or three-
dimensions, they could be used for lesion assessment.