K. Hanecke et al., Accident risk as a function of hour at work and time of day as determined from accident data and exposure models for the German working population, SC J WORK E, 24, 1998, pp. 43-48
Objectives Recent studies indicate that accident risk may be a function of
hour at work and time of day. Further evidence was sought for these assumpt
ions, along with the answer to the question of whether the risk of accident
can be conceived as an interaction between hours at work and time of day.
Methods Data on more than 1.2 million accidents for the year 1994 were prov
ided, all listed according to the time of day and hour at work. Since infor
mation about how long each day and at what time of day people work is not a
vailable in Germany, different exposure models had to be estimated. For est
imating the risk of having an accident relative accident risks were calcula
ted from the ratio of accident frequencies to the exposure data.
Results An exponentially increasing accident risk was observed beyond the 9
th hour at work. The relative accident risks differed considerably accordin
g to the respective exposure model with regard to time of day. A highly sig
nificant interaction effect was found for hour at work by time of day, the
percentage of accidents at different hours at work varying according to the
particular time of day when work is started. For the 3 "traditional" shift
work starting times, it was shown that, with later starting times, the rela
tive accident risk increased dramatically beyond the 8th hour at work.
Conclusions Since the results clearly indicate that there are time-related
effects on occupational accident risk, more detailed analyses are called fo
r. More elaborated exposure models should be used to assess the efficiency
of work schedules with extended workhours, especially under shiftwork condi
tions. The results also indicate the necessity of recording and providing a
dequate data bases for such analyses.