Variation in chemical composition and nutritional quality among barley cultivars for ruminants. 1. Steer finishing performance, diet digestibilities and carcass characteristics
Kh. Ovenell-roy et al., Variation in chemical composition and nutritional quality among barley cultivars for ruminants. 1. Steer finishing performance, diet digestibilities and carcass characteristics, CAN J ANIM, 78(3), 1998, pp. 369-375
Inherent variability in chemical composition and nutritional value exists a
mong barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) cultivars due to year grown, head morpholo
gy, growth habit and intended end use. Two trials were conducted to identif
y causal factors for variability among barley cultivars in animal performan
ce, carcass characteristics, diet digestibility and digestible energy (DE)
content. In feedlot trials, 144 large-frame beef steers (380 +/- 1.6 kg in
Trial 1, 372 +/- 0.8 kg in Trial 2) were assigned within three weight block
s, eight to a pen, in a randomized complete block design and pens to treatm
ents. Steers were fed a diet of 83% steam-rolled barley (Andre, Camelot, Cl
ark, Cougbar, Harrington or Steptoe for 123 d in Trial 1; Boyer, Camelot, C
lark, Harrington, Hesk or Steptoe for 119 d in Trial 2), 10% silage (wheat
in Trial 1, oat in Trial 2), and 7% supplement on a dry matter (DM) basis.
In Trial I, Cougbar neutral detergent fiber (NDF) digestibility was signifi
cantly lower than Clark. Digestibility of other nutrients tended to be lowe
st for steers fed Cougbar and as a result, diet DE was lower (P < 0.05) for
Cougbar than for Clark and Camelot. Diet DE and NDF digestibility were cor
related (r = 0.69; P < 0.0001). Lower nutrient utilization by steers fed Co
ugbar resulted in lower performance. In Trial 2, steers fed Hesk had a poor
er (P < 0.05) ratio of feed to gain than steers fed Camelot and Harrington
and lower (:P < 0.05) digestibility than steers fed Steptoe. In summary, da
ta from these trials suggest that Cougbar and Steptoe are of lower nutritio
nal value than other cultivars under the conditions of these studies. In th
ese studies, digestibility of NDF was a major factor contributing to differ
ences among cultivars.