Em. Barbeau et al., Does cigarette print advertising adhere to the tobacco institute's voluntary advertising and promotion code? An assessment, J PUBL H P, 19(4), 1998, pp. 473-488
Objectives. This investigation examined whether, despite the Tobacco Instit
ute's Voluntary Cigarette Advertising and Promotion Code, current cigarette
print advertising communicates culturally positive messages to youth about
smoking.
Methods. Nine hundred thirteen students in grades 6-8 (ages 10-15) were sho
wn a sample of four contemporary cigarette print ads (Camel, Marlboro, Newp
ort, and Virginia Slims) and completed structured written assessments desig
ned to capture their perceptions of each ad.
Results. Across the four ads, between 37% and 84% of the students reported
that the ads communicated to them that smoking will make people popular, co
ol, successful in life, sexy, attractive, and healthy. Sizeable percentages
of students reported that the ads show people using the product in an "exa
ggerated" way, and that what people in the ads are doing requires "exercise
and physical energy." The median estimated age of the models in the ads wa
s under age 25 for four out of the six models.
Conclusions. As perceived by adolescents, current cigarette print advertisi
ng violates basic tenets of the Voluntary Code, thus bringing into question
the tobacco industry's ability to self-regulate image advertising. These f
indings suggest that the FDA ruling to prohibit image advertising for tobac
co in publications with significant youth readership deserves serious consi
deration.