The free energy of a recently proposed new structure for the core of the 90
degrees partial dislocation in Si, displaying double the crystal periodici
ty along the dislocation line, is found to differ from that of the previous
ly accepted single-crystal period core structure by an insignificant amount
at the temperatures at which dislocations become mobile in Si. It is propo
sed, therefore, that both core structures exist. We have found that, althou
gh one should, in principle. be able to distinguish between these core stru
ctures with modern 400 kV high-resolution electron microscopes, the publish
ed experimental micrographs are unable to distinguish between these competi
ng core structures.